American Express Surprises Wall Street: Record Earnings Can't Stop the Stock Drop

Despite reporting record earnings and raising its full-year outlook, American Express faces a surprising stock slump as cautious consumer spending tempers investor expectations

Author's Avatar
Oct 18, 2024
Summary
  • Amex's record earnings and raised guidance couldn't prevent a stock drop, as cautious spending trends among affluent cardholders sparked investor concerns
Article's Main Image

American Express (AXP, Financial) delivered another strong quarter, with earnings climbing to $2.51 billion, or $3.49 per share, surpassing analysts' estimates and reflecting an 8% revenue boost to a record $16.6 billion. Yet, despite these solid numbers, investor sentiment took a hit as shares dropped nearly 5%, following management's guidance for revenue growth to land at the lower end of its 9-11% forecast. The cautious outlook aligns with consumer spending trends, as even affluent cardholders show signs of restraint, leading to a 6% rise in billing growth—steady but not stellar.

CEO Stephen J. Squeri remains bullish, raising full-year EPS guidance to $13.75-$14.05, backed by a strategic push to refresh products and attract 3.3 million new premium customers, particularly Millennials and Gen-Z, who now dominate new account growth. Meanwhile, rising credit provisions to $1.4 billion reflect higher net write-offs from increased loan volumes. CFO Christophe Le Caillec acknowledged a shift in consumer behavior, with cardholders adopting a more cautious stance amid economic uncertainty, tempering expectations for the remainder of the year.

Despite recent volatility, Amex's stock has outperformed, soaring 85% in the past twelve months, signaling confidence in its business model's resilience. Analysts like William Blair's Cristopher Kennedy see opportunities ahead, with Amex's ability to drive earnings growth without hitting the high end of revenue targets. As the company navigates a more measured growth trajectory, it's the evolving spending habits of premium customers and broader economic shifts that will shape its path forward.

Disclosures

I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and have no plans to buy any new positions in the stocks mentioned within the next 72 hours. Click for the complete disclosure